Saga of Old City: Difference between revisions
Abra Saghast (talk | contribs) m Text replacement - " - " to "—" |
|||
| (9 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{ | {{Italic title}} | ||
| name = | {{Source | ||
| image = File:SagaofOldCityCover.jpg | |name = | ||
| caption = | |image = [[File:SagaofOldCityCover.jpg|200px]] | ||
| author = [[Gary Gygax]] | |caption = Original cover artwork by Clyde Caldwell. | ||
| | |type = Novel | ||
|code = | |||
| | |edition = AD&D 1e | ||
|author = [[Gary Gygax]] | |||
| | |editor = | ||
| | |publisher = [[TSR, Inc.]] | ||
| | |cover_artist = [[Clyde Caldwell]] | ||
| | |inter_artist = [[Clyde Caldwell]] | ||
| pages = | |first published = 1985 | ||
| isbn = | |series = [[Gord the Rogue]] | ||
| | |pages = 352 | ||
|isbn = 0-88038-257-0 | |||
|class = Officially published content | |||
}} | }} | ||
'''''Saga of Old City''''' is a 1985 fantasy novel by [[Gary Gygax]], set in the | '''''Saga of Old City''''' is a 1985 fantasy novel by [[Gary Gygax]], set in the {{smallcaps|[[World of Greyhawk]]}}™. | ||
==Plot summary== | ==Plot summary== | ||
''Saga of Old City'' was the first novel to feature [[Gord the Rogue]]. ''Saga of Old City'' starts in Gord's childhood, and ends with his triumphant return to [[Free City of Greyhawk|Greyhawk City]] as a young man and master thief. He learns his trade in the ' | ''Saga of Old City'' was the first novel to feature [[Gord the Rogue]]. ''Saga of Old City'' starts in Gord's childhood, and ends with his triumphant return to [[Free City of Greyhawk|Greyhawk City]] as a young man and master thief. He learns his trade in the [[Guild of Beggars|Beggars' Guild]], and gets involved in the gang war touched off by the beggars encroaching on the official [[Guild of Thieves|Thieves' Guild's]] territory. He travels and has a variety of swashbuckling adventures, ranging from participating in a war, to travelling with the [[Rhennee]], and from liberating a young noblewoman held hostage, to defeating a demon with a druid, [[Curley Greenleaf]], and a barbarian, [[Chert]]. | ||
==Publication history== | ==Publication history== | ||
[[Gary Gygax]] wrote a short story, "At Moonset Blackcat Comes", | [[Gary Gygax]] wrote a short story, "At Moonset Blackcat Comes", which appeared in the special 100th issue of ''Dragon'' in August 1985. This introduced Gord the Rogue to gamers just before ''Saga of Old City'' was scheduled to be released.<ref>{{cite journal | last = Gygax | first = Gary | author-link=Gary Gygax | title = At Moonset Blackcat Comes | journal = Dragon | issue = 100| page = 22| publisher = TSR | location = Lake Geneva WI | date = August 1985}}</ref> ''Saga of the Old City'' was published in 1985; this and its sequel ''[[Artifact of Evil]]'' were the only two novels published under [[TSR, Inc.|TSR]]'s ''Greyhawk Adventures'' written by Gygax. | ||
This was Gygax's first novel, and it was edited by [[Kim Mohan]].<ref name="Dragon #105">{{cite journal | title = TSR Profiles | journal = [[Dragon (magazine)|Dragon]] | issue = #105 | pages = 62 | publisher = TSR, Inc. | location = | This was Gygax's first novel, and it was edited by [[Kim Mohan]].<ref name="Dragon #105">{{cite journal | title = TSR Profiles | journal = [[Dragon (magazine)|Dragon]] | issue = #105 | pages = 62 | publisher = TSR, Inc. | location = Lake Geneva, Wisconsin | date = January 1986 }}</ref> It was the first [[Greyhawk]]-branded novel,<ref name="30 Years">{{cite book|title=30 Years of Adventure: A Celebration of Dungeons & Dragons|last=Winter|first=Steve|date=October 2004|publisher=[[Wizards of the Coast]]|isbn=0-7869-3498-0|display-authors=etal}}</ref> but not the first published novel to take place in this world, which was [[Quag Keep]], published in 1978 by Andre Norton.<ref name="30 Years" /> | ||
In 2008 | In 2008 Troll Lord Games released a new hard cover reprinting of ''Saga of Old City''. (at right)[[File:SagaofOldCityCover02.jpg|175px|thumb|Cover of ''Saga of Old City'' by Troll Lord Games (2008).]] | ||
==Reception== | ==Reception== | ||
Though Gygax had written numerous adventures prior to his first novel, the plot of ''Saga of the Old City'''s shortcomings are often described that it reads like a game adventure. For an era when fantasy novels were exceedingly rare, Gygax wrote what he knew. Unfortunately, that has not stood the test of time well. | |||
On ''Goodreads'', reviewer Brian Rogers said, "This is not technically a "gaming" book because there are no rules or mechanics, but ''it is'', because it's very much AD&D. Not a surprise given its author and publisher. ...Gygax is not a thrilling prose stylist, but his vocabulary is expansive, his love of the material is clear, and his ability to pastiche the stories of Conan and his contemporaries is solid. That makes it a workable book as a fantasy adventure ''bildungsroman'' [a novel dealing with one person's formative years]. ... a series of 20-60 page tales of a young AD&D thief from his childhood and training ...to being a con man, to falling in with fantasy Romany for a while, to political skulduggery in Not-Chicago ([[Stoink]] is ruled entirely by thieves, under the control of [[Boss Dhaley]]), to wartime encounters to a classic "party of adventurers against a monster" dungeon crawl (easily the weakest part of the book). | |||
{{ | ... in this age, the casual misogyny is more noticeable. Gygax is writing in 1984, trying to write like he's working for the pulps in the 1930s, and for some reason that makes his treatment of female characters somehow worse than the Conan stories—all of the women are hapless foils or motivational tools, and none of them are as fleshed out as the women who appear in the tales Gygax is striving to emulate. It's a drag on the book overall."<ref>{{Cite web|last=Rogers|first=Brian|date=Dec 16, 2018|title=Saga of Old City| url=https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/2617880444 | website=Goodreads}}</ref> | ||
In the ''Io9'' series revisiting older ''Dungeons & Dragons'' novels, Rob Bricken commented, "I feel very weird about hating a novel written by the father of ''Dungeons & Dragons'', but there's nothing fantastic about the fantasy in ''Saga of Old City''. It's just deeply, deeply unpleasant. So while I might give the technical writing a 4 on a 1d20—he's more competent at scene and actions descriptions than R.A. Salvatore in ''The Crystal Shard'', at least Salvatore's characters were distinct and memorable—but a penalty of -2, along with a -3 for its outright misogyny. In the end, that leaves ''Saga of Old City'' with -1—technically not a critical miss, but still an utter failure."<ref>{{Cite web|last=Bricken|first=Rob|date=May 31, 2021|title=Dungeons & Dragons & Novels: Revisiting Gary Gygax's Saga of Old Town|url=https://gizmodo.com/dungeons-dragons-novels-revisiting-gary-gygaxs-sag-1846976859|url-status=live|archive-url=|archive-date=|access-date=2021-06-04|website=io9|language=en-us}}</ref> | |||
==References== | |||
===Notes=== | |||
<references group="notes" /> | |||
===Citations=== | |||
<references /> | |||
===Bibliography=== | |||
* [[Gygax, Gary|Gary Gygax]]. ''Saga of Old City''. Lake Geneva, WI: [[TSR]], 1985. | |||
{{wikipedia}} | |||
{{index}} | |||
[[Category:Sources]] | |||
[[Category:Canonical sources]] | |||
[[Category:Novels]] | |||
Latest revision as of 15:13, 26 March 2025
| Saga of Old City | |
 |
|
| Original cover artwork by Clyde Caldwell. | |
| Type: | Novel |
|---|---|
| Edition: | AD&D 1e |
| Author(s): | Gary Gygax |
| Cover Artist(s): | Clyde Caldwell |
| Interior Artist(s): | Clyde Caldwell |
| Series: | Gord the Rogue |
| Publisher: | TSR, Inc. |
| First Published: | 1985 |
| Pages: | 352 |
| ISBN: | 0-88038-257-0 |
| Class: | Officially published content |
Saga of Old City is a 1985 fantasy novel by Gary Gygax, set in the World of Greyhawk™.
Plot summary
Saga of Old City was the first novel to feature Gord the Rogue. Saga of Old City starts in Gord's childhood, and ends with his triumphant return to Greyhawk City as a young man and master thief. He learns his trade in the Beggars' Guild, and gets involved in the gang war touched off by the beggars encroaching on the official Thieves' Guild's territory. He travels and has a variety of swashbuckling adventures, ranging from participating in a war, to travelling with the Rhennee, and from liberating a young noblewoman held hostage, to defeating a demon with a druid, Curley Greenleaf, and a barbarian, Chert.
Publication history
Gary Gygax wrote a short story, "At Moonset Blackcat Comes", which appeared in the special 100th issue of Dragon in August 1985. This introduced Gord the Rogue to gamers just before Saga of Old City was scheduled to be released.[1] Saga of the Old City was published in 1985; this and its sequel Artifact of Evil were the only two novels published under TSR's Greyhawk Adventures written by Gygax.
This was Gygax's first novel, and it was edited by Kim Mohan.[2] It was the first Greyhawk-branded novel,[3] but not the first published novel to take place in this world, which was Quag Keep, published in 1978 by Andre Norton.[3]
In 2008 Troll Lord Games released a new hard cover reprinting of Saga of Old City. (at right)
Reception
Though Gygax had written numerous adventures prior to his first novel, the plot of Saga of the Old City's shortcomings are often described that it reads like a game adventure. For an era when fantasy novels were exceedingly rare, Gygax wrote what he knew. Unfortunately, that has not stood the test of time well.
On Goodreads, reviewer Brian Rogers said, "This is not technically a "gaming" book because there are no rules or mechanics, but it is, because it's very much AD&D. Not a surprise given its author and publisher. ...Gygax is not a thrilling prose stylist, but his vocabulary is expansive, his love of the material is clear, and his ability to pastiche the stories of Conan and his contemporaries is solid. That makes it a workable book as a fantasy adventure bildungsroman [a novel dealing with one person's formative years]. ... a series of 20-60 page tales of a young AD&D thief from his childhood and training ...to being a con man, to falling in with fantasy Romany for a while, to political skulduggery in Not-Chicago (Stoink is ruled entirely by thieves, under the control of Boss Dhaley), to wartime encounters to a classic "party of adventurers against a monster" dungeon crawl (easily the weakest part of the book).
... in this age, the casual misogyny is more noticeable. Gygax is writing in 1984, trying to write like he's working for the pulps in the 1930s, and for some reason that makes his treatment of female characters somehow worse than the Conan stories—all of the women are hapless foils or motivational tools, and none of them are as fleshed out as the women who appear in the tales Gygax is striving to emulate. It's a drag on the book overall."[4]
In the Io9 series revisiting older Dungeons & Dragons novels, Rob Bricken commented, "I feel very weird about hating a novel written by the father of Dungeons & Dragons, but there's nothing fantastic about the fantasy in Saga of Old City. It's just deeply, deeply unpleasant. So while I might give the technical writing a 4 on a 1d20—he's more competent at scene and actions descriptions than R.A. Salvatore in The Crystal Shard, at least Salvatore's characters were distinct and memorable—but a penalty of -2, along with a -3 for its outright misogyny. In the end, that leaves Saga of Old City with -1—technically not a critical miss, but still an utter failure."[5]
References
Notes
Citations
- ↑ Gygax, Gary (August 1985). "At Moonset Blackcat Comes". Dragon (100): 22. Lake Geneva WI: TSR.
- ↑ (January 1986). "TSR Profiles". Dragon (#105): 62. Lake Geneva, Wisconsin: TSR, Inc..
- ↑ a b Winter, Steve (October 2004) 30 Years of Adventure: A Celebration of Dungeons & Dragons, Wizards of the Coast ISBN: 0-7869-3498-0.
- ↑ Rogers, Brian. Saga of Old City. Goodreads.
- ↑ Bricken, Rob. Dungeons & Dragons & Novels: Revisiting Gary Gygax's Saga of Old Town (in en-us). io9.
Bibliography
- Gary Gygax. Saga of Old City. Lake Geneva, WI: TSR, 1985.
| This page uses Creative Commons Licensed content from Wikipedia (view authors). |
Encyclopedia Greyhawkania Index
The Encyclopedia Greyhawkania Index (EGI) is based on previous work of Jason Zavoda through '08, continued by numerous other fans. The EGI article has a list of sources, product names, abbreviations, and a link to the full, downloadable index.
| Topic | Type | Description | Product | Page/Card/Image
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Saga of Old City | Publication | Novel, | Den of Thieves | 90 |
| Saga of Old City | Publication | Novel, | Dragon magazine #100 | 23 |
| Saga of Old City | Publication | Novel, | Dragon magazine #344 | 54 |
| Saga of Old City | Publication | Novel, | Living Greyhawk Journal #2 | 19 |